PS: judging by recent photos the car in question is still part of the restaurant.

Just doing a quick search, I came up with this image. Certainly seems possible...if you think something is too wide to be narrow gauge, you've never seen a K-37 on D&RGW, or rotary plow #2 that the RGS used to use.

Ah, could be that the "The club car is GONE" wasn't meant literally, the way we would interpret it. "Who cares that they used to serve lobster and steaks and now serve fast food hamburgers, where is the passenger car?"

Oh no! I liked the Club Car! I remember sobering up there after the wine festival and being pleasantly surprised to find a train car on the island.

Forget it. They ruined it. Not that it didn't need a bit of a redo... but it's a different animal than what it was for 50 years. No elegance, no class... some euro Asian " small plates" ( so tired) train car itself has been messed up too....whatever- I'll pass in the future. Ps: atrocious new decor looks like a Palm Springs luncheonette.... turquoise is just NOT. A Nantucket. I'm sorry the management has responded with the arrogance I was surprised to read. Firstly they make complete false claims as to the decor I remarked on. Their restaurant WHEN I WAS THERE most certainly did have a shade of blue as pillows or cushions.. I really don't remember, just the shock of the off putting new design.