Railway Preservation News
https://www.rypn.org/forums/

Yes I do know what I am talking about
https://www.rypn.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=37086
Page 1 of 1

Author:  RCD [ Wed Sep 10, 2014 7:30 pm ]
Post subject:  Yes I do know what I am talking about

I rembember haveing a duschion about not being able to replace cards in a locomotive because they weren't made any more (in this case a U23B). I told them that I could probely rebuild one and the parts could be gotten at which point I was told that I was wrong and I diden't know what I was talking about. Well after looking over manueals and diegrams I can confedentely say that they can be built. Not only do these manueals give you all the vaules so you could program an emulaitor, they show you a lit of the circute layout. The only difficult thing would be if you found a property ic which last time I checked you can have custom made in China for under $100. If there is a coledge near your railroad museume you may be able yo get enginearing students to help you with your cards instead of complaneing about lack of parts.

Author:  dinwitty [ Wed Sep 10, 2014 7:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

if you can wirewrap, you can make something for almost nothing.

Just get the circuit correct. What I wonder is any specific ICs or parts are made specific for the engine.

and yes I raed perphekt mispull.

Micromart has Circuit board making kits.

If you do have the working manuals for the engine they pretty much have to give the circuit for repair requirements. No, the board might not be made anymore, but if you find the boardmaker, may...maaaybe they might have art in their resources, but yes, if your good, you can duplicate the cards.

Author:  RCD [ Thu Sep 11, 2014 8:17 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

Another thing to keep in mind is to replace the capacitors as time goes on they are ushely the first thing to fail.

Author:  wilkinsd [ Tue Sep 23, 2014 12:03 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

RCD wrote:
I rembember haveing a duschion about not being able to replace cards in a locomotive because they weren't made any more (in this case a U23B). I told them that I could probely rebuild one and the parts could be gotten at which point I was told that I was wrong and I diden't know what I was talking about. Well after looking over manueals and diegrams I can confedentely say that they can be built. Not only do these manueals give you all the vaules so you could program an emulaitor, they show you a lit of the circute layout. The only difficult thing would be if you found a property ic which last time I checked you can have custom made in China for under $100. If there is a coledge near your railroad museume you may be able yo get enginearing students to help you with your cards instead of complaneing about lack of parts.


Exhibit A on the "quality" of our educational system today. You may know what you are talking about, but if you cannot communicate in an effective manner, what good is the knowledge?

Author:  RSwinnerton [ Wed Sep 24, 2014 9:59 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

Brother Wilkins is correct. The horrendous spelling mistakes will cost you legitimacy. Spell check is your friend.
R

Author:  Zak Lybrand [ Thu Sep 25, 2014 2:22 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

RSwinnerton wrote:
Brother Wilkins is correct. The horrendous spelling mistakes will cost you legitimacy. Spell check is your friend.
R


RCD has never once, in the several years I've observed him here and on other forums, expressed even the slightest interest in acknowledging the red squiggly lines under most of the content in his posts.

Author:  Trainlawyer [ Fri Sep 26, 2014 2:27 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

I believe I took some flak a while ago because I pointed out that it was difficult to take a discussion of safety policies too seriously when, when among things, the initial poster misspelled 'safety' and did not correct it after several very strong hints. It was then pointed out to me that several of the spelling errors resembled a reading problem rather than just poor spelling. There have frequently been points worthy of discussion buried within his posts. I am going to suggest that we cut RCD a little bit bit of slack on the errors if he will make a good faith effort to acknowledge and act on the red squiggly lines. I am also going to suggest again that he talk to a reading or adult literacy specialist. As Brother Peartree pointed out in the previous thread, there are quite a number of people who have such difficulties and have overcome them.
wilkinsd wrote:
Exhibit A on the "quality" of our educational system today. You may know what you are talking about, but if you cannot communicate in an effective manner, what good is the knowledge?
Absolutely true. Below is the corrected version of the original post. Except for two words it was done by the spell checker on my laptop. Brother de la Barre is invited to further correct anything I got wrong.
RCD, as spellchecked by GME's laptop, wrote:
I remember having a discussion about not being able to replace cards in a locomotive because they weren't made any more (in this case a U23B). I told them that I could probably rebuild one and the parts could be gotten at which point I was told that I was wrong and I didn’t know what I was talking about. Well after looking over manuals and diagrams I can confidently say that they can be built. Not only do these manuals give you all the values so you could program an emulator, they show you a bit of the circuit layout. The only difficult thing would be if you found a proprietary IC which last time I checked you can have custom made in China for under $100. If there is a college near your railroad museum you may be able to get engineering students to help you with your cards instead of complaining about lack of parts.

GME

Author:  dinwitty [ Fri Sep 26, 2014 9:00 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

we don't know the age or skills, but he shows spunk and some ability and he is correct about replacing PC boards and it disappoints me in the abilities as to whom he may be referencing to. I find myself spell checking a lot and editing posts myself but sometimes teh misspull brakes trew....

Author:  wilkinsd [ Fri Sep 26, 2014 10:33 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

Communication, both written and oral, is what I do for a living. To me, if the op does have a problem, I think it must be horrible, you can form coherent thoughts in your head but communicating them in an effective manner is a problem. It must be hell.

However, spellcheck is your friend, it will fix most of the problems, and yes, an error slips by every now and then.

Author:  dinwitty [ Fri Sep 26, 2014 9:06 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

RCD wrote:
I remember having a discussion about not being able to replace cards in a locomotive because they weren't made any more (in this case a U23B). I told them that I could probably rebuild one and the parts could be gotten at which point I was told that I was wrong and I didn't know what I was talking about. Well after looking over manuals and diagrams I can confidently say that they can be built. Not only do these manuals give you all the values so you could program an emulator, they show you a lot of the circuit layout. The only difficult thing would be if you found a proprietary IC which last time I checked you can have custom made in China for under $100. If there is a college near your railroad museum you may be able yo get engineering students to help you with your cards instead of complaining about lack of parts.


Spell checked/interpreted

I remember some gal somewhere working some college project and contacted a local electronic manufacturer, she gave them a circuit to plug into some custom Intergrated circuit and they produced some IC's with her circuit.

strange I would remember that but some things jog your brain and this post did that.
If your resourceful, you can do anything.

Author:  Alexander D. Mitchell IV [ Sat Sep 27, 2014 4:43 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

Anyone who says "you can't replace circuit boards/cards" has never seen the ingenuity of the typical ham radio or electronics hobbyist, or the "hackers" who build new computer controls to "soup up" modern cars into "hot rods." The valid question is, "is it worth doing?" This also sounds like steam guys exploiting a prejudice against diesels, of the old "when all you have is a shovel, everything looks like a pile of coal/dung" ilk.

The other question is, is the documentation necessary to replicate such things as modular cards being saved anywhere? It's far easier to simply replicate something, or better yet build a whole new way of doing the task, when the design documentation is available, instead of having to "reverse engineer" the thing. ("WTF were these guys thinking?!?!?" is a phrase that emanates from underneath too many car hoods today. "Seriously, you built a coolant connecting tube out of the same plastic in the manifold to make it integral, not thinking that propylene glycol attacks that plastic??")

Author:  robertmacdowell [ Mon Oct 06, 2014 2:37 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

RCD wrote:
I rembember haveing a duschion about not being able to replace cards in a locomotive because they weren't made any more (in this case a U23B). I told them that I could probely rebuild one and the parts could be gotten at which point I was told that I was wrong and I diden't know what I was talking about. Well after looking over manueals and diegrams I can confedentely say that they can be built.


In a communications medium based on writing, it's kind of a kneejerk for me to judge by writing. Fortunately, electrons don't care. Do it and laugh. Or laff if you prefer :)

What I run into, trying to overhaul old cards, is either a) you find a discrete component that is not properly labeled, or if labeled, unobtainable; ... or b) cards where the card (the insulating material) has rotted out or gone brittle and it can no longer hold up to the task at hand.

Quote:
Not only do these manueals give you all the vaules so you could program an emulaitor, they show you a lit of the circute layout. The only difficult thing would be if you found a property ic which last time I checked you can have custom made in China for under $100.

Or replace the IC with a programmable controller, to wit an Arduino or Raspberry Pi, which are sold at Radio Shack as children's toys.

For instance, in voltage regulator boards, today we understand a great deal more about optimum battery charging than we did years ago. So batteries don't boil off water and last a lot longer. That "modern sense" could be programmed into a replica battery charger circuit if you are using a programmable controller.

Author:  robertmacdowell [ Mon Oct 06, 2014 11:29 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

And here's another wrinkle for those seeking to replace old microprocessors. Here's a board based computer that can programmed to emulate any older computer in hardware.
https://code.google.com/p/mist-board/wiki/WhatIsThis

Author:  PCook [ Mon Nov 24, 2014 12:15 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Yes I do know what I am talking about

Alexander D. Mitchell IV wrote:
The other question is, is the documentation necessary to replicate such things as modular cards being saved anywhere?


Yes, there are people trying to preserve such information, but this is being done primarily through individual efforts, and it would help if the national organizations were to become more active in the preservation of technical documentation by maintaining electronic archives to help make it available for those who need it in the future.

PC

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/